The GDC’s proposal to default to remote hearings ‘could potentially compromise fairness’, according to an indemnity provider.
The MMDUS has warned that the plans could ‘severely limit’ many registrants’ ability to engage in the process.
In November, the GDC invited views on the proposals. These mean all practice committee and registration appeal committee hearings will be held remotely by default. It will, however, receive requests for hearings to be held in-person and says these will ‘be considered’ and ‘decided fairly’.
Around 90% of hearings are currently held remotely. Since 2022, the GDC says it has had 42 applications for a hearing to be held either in-person or hybrid. Five of these applications were not accepted.
Without justification
Rachael Bell, interim head of dental at MDDUS, said: ‘Everyone has a right to a fair and public hearing and the GDC’s proposal to default to remote hearings could potentially compromise this fairness.
‘In cases with conflicting factual accounts, registrants should have the right to see their accuser face-to-face without providing justification for such a request.’
Rachael Bell added: ‘For many, a smartphone may be their only way to participate in remote hearings. This can severely limit registrants’ ability to engage fully in the process.
‘The GDC’s effort to manage resources must not come at the cost of fairness, particularly for those with learning difficulties, sensory impairments, disabilities or other challenges.’
‘Considerable benefits’, says GDC
John Cullinane is the executive manager of dental professionals hearings service. He said: ‘We think there are considerable benefits to holding hearings remotely, not least savings in travel and accommodation costs, but also reductions in lost hearing days due to travel disruptions and increased participation from those who find it difficult to be away from home.
‘Since we started holding most of our hearings remotely, we have introduced additional support for all hearing participants by providing specific guidance on attending a remote hearing and introducing a participant support officer to address the challenges that these types of proceedings may present.
‘Our view is that the process for deciding the format of hearings has been working well. We can now realise the benefits for all parties by making the process permanent.’
The consultation on the format of hearings is currently open. Professionals can review the proposals and provide their views by 15 February 2024.
Follow Dentistry.co.uk on Instagram to keep up with all the latest dental news and trends.
What are your thoughts on this story? Send them to [email protected]
