Edmund Proffitt, chief executive of the BDIA, discusses the risks of buying counterfeit dental equipment and how to avoid it.
The internet is rife with counterfeit and sub-standard dental equipment. And, while we all love a bargain – it’s human nature – don’t risk your patients’ safety, or your registration, for a cheap deal.
Most of us buy online almost daily now, from the weekly grocery shop to major purchases like holidays and cars. There are, indeed, great deals to be had. But the internet has also opened the floodgates to a problem that is growing in all sectors, including dentistry: the sale of counterfeit, sub-standard and even stolen goods. These are often virtually impossible to differentiate from the genuine product and are at best illegal and at worst downright dangerous.
The most common cheap copies tend to be disposable items. But higher value products – such as handpieces, curing lights and even x-ray equipment, mostly made in China – are widely counterfeited. They are sold through sites such as Ali Baba, Amazon and Ebay and are finding their way into dental practices around the UK.
The fakes are growing in sophistication. They appear to have CE marks, bar codes, serial numbers and holographic labels – all counterfeit. Even the accompanying documentation is expertly forged to be indistinguishable to the untrained eye.
Durability and longevity
A growing number of products which turn out to be copies are being sent to dental equipment manufacturers with complaints about their performance or quality. Authentic items such as handpieces, which are especially widely counterfeited, are high-quality instruments developed by specialist manufacturers for professionals to use.
The named brands are continually investing in research and development to ensure that they bring you innovations in handpieces. This is so you can achieve the best treatment results safely – and this is reflected in the prices.
Cheaper, lower-quality copies can be bought online. But where quality is an issue, is it really worth staking a professional reputation for a price deal? The power and speed of a dental handpiece means it is critical that it is produced using high-quality materials and to a consistently high standard for durability and longevity: otherwise, you risk compromising the safety of your team and your patients.
Managing director of handpiece manufacturer W&H Sonia Tracey said: ‘We use serial numbers and unique data matrix coding on each item so we can trace our products; dentists are knowingly using illegal, non-compliant products, risking both their patients’ safety and their own professional registration.’
Managing director of NSK United Kingdom Ltd Alex Breitenbach agrees. ‘Where you buy from, and the price that is charged, should be your first clue it may be a fake,’ he said.
‘Once the product is in your hand it’s already too late to wonder whether it’s not what it seems.’
The Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) has seized many thousands of items since turning its attention to dental equipment. MHRA colleagues have seen some shocking examples of items that break down almost immediately. They are also liable to disintegrate in the patient’s mouth, as well as a batch of X-ray equipment that used cheap kitchen foil instead of lead to block radiation.
However, the counterfeiters are growing increasingly clever and sophisticated. MHRA colleagues tell us: ‘Recognising a fake just by looking at it is very hard. The time to suspect that an item is counterfeit or substandard is before you even purchase it. Check the chain of supply and look at where the product has come from.
‘Websites can look very convincing, but major manufacturers do not sell their products on Ebay. Caveat emptor is entirely applicable here.’
The General Dental Council reinforces this advice. It urges all registrants to ‘carry out appropriate checks to ensure the products they are purchasing, or commissioning are legitimate’.
Get to know your suppliers
The problem of counterfeiting has become so rife that the British Dental Industry Association (BDIA) launched its Counterfeit and Sub-standard Instruments and Devices Initiative (CSIDI) several years ago to fight it, to protect its members, the profession and the general public. There is more information on the BDIA website, and an easy way to report anything suspicious is through this link.
The key is to get to know your suppliers. BDIA members adhere to a strict code of practice. This gives dentists the confidence that the products they buy are of guaranteed quality and provenance.
The bottom line is to buy from reputable suppliers and know where your product is coming from. It is not worth risking your patients’ or staff’s safety – or your professional registration. Remember the adage: if the price is too good to be true – it probably is.